The Legacy of Mark Blumsky

Return to Pole Essay

 

Return to Welcome  Page

 

Return to Update Page

 

This pole was placed here as recently as 1988-something I can vouch to as I owned the land it is on at the time.

A short biography of Hon Mark Blumksy can be read on Wiki.

He was endorsed by the previous mayor, Fran Wilde and became mayor of Wellington City in 1995. The biography fails to mention that his administration was responsible for the sale in 1996 of the remaining Council holdings of 51% of Capital Power for a “nuts and bolts” price - or more accurately, at the price that TransAlta dictated to him as they already had management rights and so had been able to rearrange the company to suit their interests.

At this point the city lost all control over its wiring utility grid with the exception of the trolley bus wiring system and some optic fibre linking the CBD. Most of the city’s electrical potential was destroyed. Already under the Fran Wilde Administration processes were firmly in place to destroy critical elements of the grids intelligence.

It is essential to understand that the new overseas owners, TransAlta of Calgary, Canada, had very different interests to those of the Wellington Community. The community has a fundamental interest  in the efficient uses of the city’s potential and reducing carbon emissions.

By contrast TransAlta’s interest was in promoting sales of Bulk-generated electricity and maximimising returns off its thermal fired generating plant.

Now wholesale sackings of staff occurred and security systems, developed over 80 years were dismantled. For instance the keys and access data entrusted to the Council by generations of Wellington citizens were given away without any consideration of the risks involved and the decisions of Mayor Blumksy made it very easy for criminals to infiltrate the new security systems.

The impotency of Mayor Blumksy is illustrated in these two examples.

A shonky deal was struck that enabled Saturn to string optic fibre cables onto the utility poles of Wellington ’s wiring grid. There was widespread public concern about the visual pollution this would  cause. Saturn assured the Wellington people they would only be installing finger thick wires. This was a lie and in many areas Saturn installed wrist thick cables.

 

I contacted Mayor Blumsky and suggested this would severely stress the grid and could result in its collapse in a “Wahine-scale” storm. We needed assurances this would not occur. \

(Note as an "employee", albeit under sub-contract, of Capital Power-TransAlta until late 1997 my ability to speak out more generally was very limited.) 

This was about 1996-7, the same time that Mayor Blumsky called a series of public meeting to discuss the predicament the council was now in – funding reserves had dried up and he was strawpolling the citizens as to which city services he would cut. It was pointed out to Mayor Blumsky at his Newtown meeting that other city’s that had retained control of their electricity companies and the flows of funds off them were expanding services. I reminded the Mayor that the city had now lost much of it Civil Defense capacity and the grid was possibly overstressed because of the Saturn deal.

His CEO responded on Mayor Blumsky’s behalf and said they had made inquiries in response to my concerns and he could assure the meeting that “Mr McArthur need have no cause for concern at all – the city’s grid structure was well capable of supporting Saturn’s cables.

Wellington has been fortunate. It has not experienced a “Wahine-scale” storm yet within five years of this assurance there was growing evidence that Mayor Blumksy’s advise was very ill informed. A decade on and the system is visibly over-stressed. Also in some regions of the city the Wellington substations were so run down that by 2006 citizens were receiving a quality of delivery that is rated Third World status.

The 1998 Electricity Reform act forced TransAlta to sell its grid in  Wellington City . It ended up in the control of Utilicorp (now Aquila ), another North American corporation. This corporation continued TransAlta’s policy of gutting the grid and it too sold out in 2003. Fortunately the new owners, Auckland community owned Vector Ltd, have been far finer stewards of the Wellington people.

 

Working steadily the team could replace one pole a day. This did not include hanging the Saturn - TelstraClear cables. Note: Telecom trenched its cable under the road beacons at the same time as Saturn were stringing their large cables overhead.

A very reliable source informed me Vector has “inherited a nightmare system with poles incorrectly wired and overstressed by the Saturn cabling.” It has embarked on an extensive programme to save the grid from collapsing. Recently I mentioned to a City Councillor, Jack Rubens, how grateful we should be that the Auckland people have assumed responsibility for our grid and why. He said all Councillors knew is that Vector had applied to replace 1800 poles across Wellington city but did not know why!

Now it is possible that control of the city’s wiring grid is about to revert to overseas bankers again with Vector selling it to Babcock and Brown. It is safe to predict that if this occurs  that Wellington ’s citizens will have to sit helpless and watch funds flow out of the region, pushing the WCC deeper into debt. They will also fail to enjoy many of the enormous benefits that the convergence of technologies will bring to communities that own their wiring grids.

A second indication of the impotency of Mayor Blumsky occurred when Saturn technicians were stringing up cables in my street. Telecom had trenched the street for a considerable distance to replace a damaged cable. I contacted all the lines companies plus Mayor Blumsky and alerted them that this was an ideal opportunity to bury all cables in this high-wind, high-scenic value area. Privately the companies told me they would not consider sharing a trench.(1) Publicly they said otherwise.

Mayor Blumsky could only wring his hands helplessly, agree that it made great sense to trench all the cables and say he could do nothing about it because the council agreement with utilities such as Telecom meant they only had to give the Wellington City Council three weeks notice of their intention to trench our roads. He had no ability anymore to coordinate and rationalise grid services for the city.

Note: Wellington City is now sinking deep into debt and since 2000 has been heavily subsidised by the Government.

Note (1):  A senior Saturn Manager told me that they would not share the trench with Telecom because “.. they are a nasty pack of bastards and just look for any excuse to sue us… so we stay well clear of them.”
Such is the fractured and conflicted state of the Wellington city wiring grid.

 Return to Pole Essay

Return to Welcome  Page

Return to Update Page

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 


.
.